Saturday, April 12, 2008

The Trouble With The Elephant, II

This is part 2 of my series The Trouble With The Elephant. Part 1 can be found be found by clicking the link. Here, in part 2, I am following up with Gloria's request for more information.

Gloria:

Okay, I spent a good portion of today, off and on, writing this especially for you.

I will be honest and upfront. I think that I am right and everyone else should think basically like I do. But, if you really think about it, that is perfectly reasonable and rational because no one walks around thinking their religious views (or lack thereof) are wrong and still keeps those views.

Most everyone is motivated by a combination of emotion and reason. I tend to first be motivated by mostly logical arguments, and then my emotions. Some people it is the other way around. I don't know what motivates you best when it comes to these matters, but I am hoping that you will come to the same conclusions that I have. Since I don't know you well enough to tailor my arguments to your personality, I am just going to keep going with the autobiographical sort of self-dialog I have started.

When it comes to religion, I eventually became concerned with what is true. A belief, hypothesis, or proposition about reality is true if and only if it accurately describes the way reality really is.

Many people view religion as a sort of spiritual hobby, hence the adage “find something that works for you.” They see it as something that can give them meaning in life, something that they find they agree with, something that appeals to them, something to provide a framework for ethics and some sort of spiritual comfort, as well as some kind of hope of life after death. I cannot tell you the number of times I used (and heard) the phrase, “all religions teach basically the same stuff, to do the right thing.” (Often people will have no religion because they see it as a crutch and they don't need some religion to tell them the right thing to do.)

This was part of the reason I became a Chan Buddhist. I was a martial arts student for a while (Hung Gar Kung Fu) and was introduced to the religion that way. It appealed to me because I liked how it described the world, the ethics were great, and over all it was beautiful and provided meaning for my life. It also helped provide some inner peace.

In addition, it is very tolerant. For example, it did not claim that you had to be a Buddhist to go to heaven. Just keep doing the right thing and eventually you will get there . . . if there is such a place. Actually, Chan practitioners never really bother themselves with questions of god, heaven, hell, afterlife, etc. Those things are just not of interest. I didn't need some god to bribe or threaten me to get me to do the right thing. Such things were, at best, a crutch.

Many people also view all the different religions as different perspectives of the same basic idea, i.e., do the right thing. That was my view. Either “god” revealed “himself” in many different forms, or people are expressing their view of god differently. Live and let live, as far as I was concerned. Just don’t mess with me, or I’ll put my Hung Gar Kung Fu mojo on you.

You probably have heard the story of the Indian Raj who saw three blind men feeling an elephant. One blind man felt the tusk and declared “An elephant is just like a spear!” Another blind man felt the tail and declared “No, the elephant is like a rope.” The third blind man felt the elephant’s side and declared “No, an elephant it truly like a wall.” However, the Raj saw that each man only perceived a piece of the truth and the men had to basically combine their views to get the correct picture.

This is often said about the world’s religions and that people are intolerant for saying others religions are "wrong" because we all are only feeling part of the elephant. We should not be so intolerant and declare our way to god/heaven the only right one. The nerve of those bigots! Besides, who cares what people think, as long as they do the right thing and don't hurt others. That is how I felt?

However, I eventually realized there is a problem with the elephant. On further reflection, it turns out this story is really just poor thinking and is a self-refuting line of logic. It is sadly is used as a cliché.

Here is the trouble with the elephant – the Raj was not blind and was in the privileged position to see the truth and declare what the truth was. Only someone who can see and has access to the truth is able to declare the other men wrong and state what the elephant is really like. (Also, what if the elephant could talk and tell us about itself? I am not being silly here, but am making a metaphorical comment about "revealed" religion.)

However, those who use the elephant story with respect to religion are claiming that everyone is wrong and each religions, like each blind man, only have part of the truth. But if everyone is wrong, then they are wrong too and can make no such claim. They are blind just like us.

However, if they are right in their claim that we only perceive part of the truth, how is it that they (like the Raj) are in the privileged position to see the truth? How is it they can see (the truth) while the rest of us are blind, as they claim?

This is not just a fancy play on words or a word trick, but reveals a fundamental and fatal flaw in their thinking. Their claim is logically self-refuting and cannot be true or of value.

In addition, often those who claim that sincere religious believers are intolerant “fundamentalists” because these fundamentalists think other religions are wrong, are the same people who use the elephant story to say everyone is wrong and they happen to see the truth.

They are exhibiting self-refuting intolerance that they vociferously condemn in others. (Many people believe that good thinking is using the wittiest clichés quickly. All that is really happening is a rapid fire tossing of valueless clichés! Take just about any non-science college course.)

I realized that not everyone can be right about religion. Either there is a God, or there isn’t. Hence either atheists or theists are right. There is no middle ground. They cannot both be right. If there is a God, there is either one God, or more than one God. Hence monotheists are right, or polytheists are right. They cannot both be right. God is either personal, or not. Hence either Jews, Christians, Muslims, etc. are right, or Hindus, Taoists, etc. are right. They cannot both be. God is either separate from man, or not. God is either transcendent, or not. God is either triune, or not. Jesus is either God, or he was not.

It is possible for everyone to be wrong, but with all the mutually exclusive religious views around, it is not possible for everyone to be right.

I wanted to know what the truth was, not what made me feel good. I realized that there are times when the truth is the most important thing, and what makes you feel good can be fatal. Metaphorically speaking, if I had cancer and was fighting it with chemotherapy drugs, I would be a fool to walk into my doctor’s office and tell her, “You know, this chemo stuff makes me sick and I don’t feel so good. So I am going to substitute chocolate syrup and fight the cancer that way.” (Notice I sensitively used a female authority figure … no sexist here!)

This was not a dispassionate exercise of logical reasoning, I was actually pretty worried. Just like when I look both ways before crossing the street, I figured I better know what is going on rather than blithely walk into spiritual traffic. Jeez, what if the Muslims are right? Allah might be upset and I don’t want to get blind-sided by that.

This line of thinking started me down the path to wondering two things, (1) Is there a God?, and (2) Does it matter?

In any event, I will stop here for now. If you want more, let me know. Please feel free to ask questions. Remember, I want to persuade you to my point of view and I can hardly do that if you are not asking questions. (Once again, being transparent here.)

Thursday, April 10, 2008

The Trouble With The Elephant, I

I am starting a series titled The Trouble With The Elephant. In this series, I am reporting actual correspondance with a friend, Gloria, why I left Buddhism for Christianity.

Dear Gloria:
Regarding the concept behind Yin and Yang. First, I am oversimplifying in my response. The Tao that can be told is not the true Tao.

Second, it represents not only the concept of "balance" we can all agree with, e.g., balancing work and fun, family and private time, food and exercise, etc., but it also represents a basic monistic view of the world/nature/existence.

Tao produced the One. The One produced the two. The two produced the three. And the three produced the ten thousand things. Tao produced the One. The ten thousand things carry the yin and embrace the yang, and through the blending of the material force they achieve harmony. Tao Te Ching, Chpt 42.

Ultimately when you boil things down to their essence, this view teaches, and the Yin Yang symbolizes, all positive and negative, creative and destructive, moral and immoral are just opposite sides of the same coin. In fact, the positive even has some of the negative inherent in it, and the negative has some of the positive inherent in it too. Hence the white "eye" in the black part, and the black "eye" in the white part of the Yin Yang symbol.

It teaches that, in reality, good and evil are opposite sides of the same coin, they are both co-equal and co-eternal, and the only real difference between them is our perception. This view teaches that the real problem lies with our perception, not with the existence of evil, because, after all (as the cliche' goes): "how could you know good without evil?", "how could you have good without evil?", etc.

Please note that I am not talking about what humans might have perverted the view to hold, but what the view itself (as expressed in the I-Ching, Tao Te Ching, and Taoist/Budhhist scholars) actually does teach. Morality and immorality, good and evil, and not fundamentally different, but actually different aspects of the same thing and it is our perception that makes them different. All is illusion, our individual minds are illusion, we are all just splinters of the one and a monistic view of the universe is supposed to be the ultimate reality.

I also want to be very clear that I am not saying Buddhists or Taoist are somehow immoral or believe it is acceptable to behave in an evil fashion. This is not the case. A classic example are the Tibetan's patient and gentle suffering, exemplified by the Dalai Lama's life, under the oppression of a foreign conqueror, the Communist Chinese government. Would only the mainline Christian world take their cue from the Tibetans.

I eventually reached the point where I did not believe good and evil are only different in perception, nor co-equal and co-eternal. The torture and murder of 6 million Jews, or the torture and murder of your or my child is not only different because of perception. I do not believe good and evil are opposite sides of the same thing.

If you are interested in more (I hope you are), I will explain. But I don't want to bore you too much.

Dear Jarrod,
I am definitely interested in more. Growing up, my parents left religion in our hands. Religious beliefs and scripts were up to us to investigate and decide what we believed in and what faith we chose for ourselves. I feel the most "at home" with the buddhist religion and my brother feels at home with christianity. My parents are fine with both. It wasn't until after we had made our choices that my parents told us that our family was indeed buddhist. So what you told me was little of what I already knew and a little enlightening as well. I don't remember where I first heard it, but it made sense. Anything else you want to share, I welcome.....Please....continue....

My Son Learns an Important Lesson

This past weekend we celebrated my father's 71st birthday and my grandmother's 90th birthday. The wife and I were excited to visit them on their ranch, but not nearly excited as my son. For nearly a week before going to the ranch, my son was asking every minute "Are we leaving now? When do we get to see Grampa Jelly?" He loves helping 'Grampa Jelly' on the ranch.

Naturally I was proud to see my son learning some of the same lessons I learned on the ranch, especially the lesson about awareness of your surroundings that occurs around 17-20 seconds into the video.


Ohio bill would require parents to volunteer at school or pay fine

Just got this from an NEA MorningUpdate. It's about time.

Ohio's Plain Dealer (4/9, Gonzalez) reported, "A bill introduced in the Ohio legislature would require parents to donate at least 13 hours to their school district each year or pay" a $100 fine. "And, if parents failed to pay up, the fine could be deducted from their state income tax refunds." The bill would also require that school districts "report parents who [do not] volunteer to the Ohio Department of Education" and provide mentors for students. Furthermore, "mentors would have to undergo criminal background checks and complete an annual training course developed by the district." Rep. Stephen Dyer (D) acknowledged that the bill "may have to undergo revisions in committee," but said, "Ensuring that parents play a vital role in their children's life is the reason I signed on to it."

Tuesday, April 08, 2008

Homeschooling Poll

I have added a poll to get your opinion of the recent California Homeschooling decision. Please let me know what you think. I am not sure if the poll is working properly. If not, please leave a comment and let me know.


Monday, April 07, 2008

My Wife's A Shooter, part 2

As mentioned in my previous post, I mentioned that my wife was a volunteer student at AllSafe Defense Systems' NRA Pistol Instructor course.
This course is designed to train experienced shooters the techniques necessary to teach the basics of Pistol marksmanship.
In order to do this, the class needed novices who would volunteer to be taught by the student-instructors. There were approximately nine student volunteers; my wife was one of four women in the group.

We arrived at 8:45 for the 9 am course. When we entered we were promptly greeted and given name tags by a friendly woman who was a student-instructor. As volunteer-students, we were given seats in the front for the classroom portion of the day. (Thereafter we were to go to the range to test the student-instructor's ability to teach us.)

(Note: technically, as I had some prior firearms experience I was not a volunteer-student, but accompanied my wife. We agreed ahead of time that I would watch the whole time, but Mr. TJ Johnston was very kind and allowed me to be involved in some of the lessons. Hence, when I say we in this post, I really mean the student-volunteers with me watching nearby.)

Most of the classroom portion of the day was spent with each student-instructor given 3 minutes to teach us an aspect of the lesson. As a professional educator, I really appreciated the designed format for the instruction. None of the student-instructors were permitted to teach anything via giving us a lecture. Rather, they continually asked questions of the volunteer students, guiding the questions they were asking and our answers to help us discover for ourselves the lessons to be learned.

This is a classic example of student-centered instruction, resulting in an active learning environment. The students discovered for themselves (under careful, rigorous supervision) the elements of gun safety, proper stance, sight alignment, sight picture, breathing, trigger control, etc. This is in contradistinction to the type of direct-instruction that leads into instructor-centered learning and a passive learning environment. (E.g., remember college and hours of rapid note-taking?)

The student-instructors then quickly moved us into actually handling (unloaded) Ruger semi-automatic .22 pistols to review and apply the lessons we learned under the careful eye of the student-instructors and the head instructor.

Thereafter we went to the Orange County Indoor Range to practice our skills. I watched intently and noticed that the student-instructors were primarily interested in the volunteers gaining proficiency while having a good time, as opposed to pushing the volunteers to do well so the student-instructors would look good in the class. Like good teachers, they put their students first and wanted them (us) to develop a love for the sport rather than merely doing well themselves ... which is why the student-instructors did so well with their volunteers.

In fact, my wife at the beginning was starting out too tense and not performing as well as she could. She was nervous that if she did not do well enough, that her three student-instructors might not pass the class. They quickly put her mind to rest and told her just to relax and enjoy what she was doing, not worry about them. It was obvious to her that these three men meant exactly what they said, and she immediately began to relax.

Consequently, her performance improved to well that, despite being a total novice who never held a gun before scored a 78 on the rapid fire portion of the drills. The student-instructors were genuinely so please with her performance that one of them gave me a thumb-up and whispered to me "Whatever you do, don't make her mad." An obvious reference to her newly acquired skills.

Thereafter, the class ended with a debriefing session wherein the student-instructors evaluated their volunteer's performance and how they (the instructors) could improve the volunteer's skills. The volunteers also gave the head instructor (TJ Johnston) honest feedback on the student-instructors' strengths and weaknesses. I watched intently as the student-instructors paid careful attention to the feedback with the purpose of improving their teaching skills.

I won't go into all the details here, but I want to end with one closing observation. Mr Johnston also was very careful to appropriately ask each female volunteer if they felt talked down to, made to feel uncomfortable in anyway, or treated negatively due to their gender. It was obvious to me that he really meant this and wanted to be sure no one was treated differently due to being female. Every woman volunteer answered that they were treated just fine and did not feel discriminated against because they were female.

The only down side to our day with AllSafe Defense Systems is that now I am going to have to spend even more money ... buying my wife ammunition. She has really developed a love of shooting and has gotten the bug.

Thank you Mr. Johnston and the student-instructors at AllSafe. It was a really positive experience for the two of us.

(And for those of you student-instructors who are law enforcement or military, Thank you for your service. "We sleep safely in our beds because rough men stand ready in the night to visit violence on those who would do us harm.")

Friday, April 04, 2008

Criticism of Science versus Intelligent Design

I recently received a criticism of my article Science versus Intelligent Design by "Steve." I appreciate the criticism and am glad he left the comment.

In his comment, Steve said:
Spoken like an true Adventist and creationist. What you have succeeded in doing is simply regurgitating the Discovery Institute's arguement that science should change its essential methodology to accomodate your religious longings.

As pointed out by Intelligent Design advocate Dr. Michael Behe at the Dover trial - by allowing supernatural explanations into the realm of science one might just as well replace astronomy with astrology and chemistry with alchemy.

I'd rather not return to 13th century mysticism, thanks.

My first question is in response to Steve's initial statement.

What you have succeeded in doing is simply [arguing] that science should change its essential methodology to accomodate [sic] your religious longings.
Steve, there is more than one prevalent philosophy of science. Examples are materialism, methodological naturalism, naturalism, scientism, etc. All of these, to my knowledge, are argued for philosophically (or even theologically) and are a priori to scientific inquiry. They are not demonstrated to be true, or to be the correct methodology for scientific inquiry, by any scientific test that I am aware of.

If that is the case, then why am I not allowed the same opportunity to philosophically argue a methodology of science that I believe accurately describes the way the world really is?
allowing supernatural explanations into the realm of science one might just as well replace astronomy with astrology and chemistry with alchemy.
Why? Is it because one is concerned that, rather than looking for natural laws that explain the physical world, science will devolve into a mere "because God said so"? That is fine if you wish to argue the case, but please realize that you are not demonstrating any of this to be true via any actual use of the scientific method. You are arguing for it philosophically, but than are barring me from the same avenue of reasoning.
I'd rather not return to 13th century mysticism, thanks.
Neither would I. However, I don't believe that is the only available alternative to naturalism, materialism, what-have-you. I believe this is a false dichotomy.

Steve, I don't mind the criticism at all, but please show me where I am wrong.

California parents arrested — Caught Home-schooling their children without a teaching credential

Sacramento, California - A three-judge panel from the 2nd District Court of Appeals made it illegal on February 28 for any parent to home school their child, unless they have a teaching or tutor credential. Upon hearing the ruling, school districts officials began demanding that police take immediate action. So yesterday, throughout the state, judges secretly began swearing out and signing arrest warrants for any parent who was suspected of home-schooling their children without a teaching credential.

Setting up a special task force virtually overnight, SWAT teams and truant officers armed with arrest warrants and automatic weapons began rounding up wayward parents, and against their will placing their child in protective custody and enrolling them in public schools throughout the state.

Originally thought to be a logistical nightmare, distinguishing home-schooled children from that of the public school system, officials quickly learned they could gather up a list of suspects from [you can read more about it here]

Parental Rights to Homeschool Children

The folks over at Life, Liberty and Family posted today (Parental Rights to Home School Children) that, in response to the In re Rachel L. decision which effectively outlaws homeschooling in California, Congressman Howard McKeon (R-CA) introduced a resolution (H. Res. 1076) into the House supporting the rights of parents to home school their children.

The resolution, with 32 co-sponsors, calls upon the California Court of Appeals to
"... uphold United States Supreme Court precedent which recognizes the fundamental and constitutional rights of parents to direct the upbringing and education of their children."
The Resolution can be found here by typing H.Res. 1076 into the bill search box.

Thursday, April 03, 2008

My Wife's a Shooter


I am a member of Front Sight Firearms Training Institute owned and operated by Dr. Igantius Piazza. Front Sight has the greatest firearms training facilities open to the public in the world, in my opinion.

Well, a while back I decided that I wanted my wife to learn to use a handgun in order to protect herself. Despite the bias against guns, especially the canard that a gun in the home increases the likelihood it will be used against the family, current statistics show that approximately 500 women use a gun to prevent a crime against themselves every day.

In a truly moral and civilized society, people exclusively interact through persuasion. Force has no place as a valid method of social interaction, and the only thing that removes force from the menu is the personal firearm, as paradoxical as it may sound to some.

When I carry a gun, you cannot deal with me by force. You have to use reason and try to persuade me, because I have a way to negate your threat or employment of force.

The gun is the only personal weapon that puts a 100-pound woman on equal footing with a 220-pound mugger, a 75-year old retiree on equal footing with a 19-year old gang banger, and a single guy on equal footing with a carload of drunk guys with baseball bats. The gun removes the disparity in physical strength, size, or numbers between a potential attacker and a defender. --Maj. L. Caudill USMC (Ret)
Given that I love my wife dearly, I want to be sure she is taken care of if I am not around. Hence, I signed her up for a special free gun offer by Front Sight which, for $1200, included not only a 4 Day Defensive Handgun course and a number of other goodies, but also included a Springfield Armory 40-caliber XD.

I consulted with several female members of Front Sight about the best way to prepare my wife for the 4 Day Defensive Handgun Class. In addition to the kind of gear she would likely need, they suggested that I take my wife to the range to get her used to firing a gun.

The best advice came from both Kim and Bob that I should take my wife out to AllSafe Defense Systems run by TJ Johnston to take a course before she goes out to Front Sight.

I will write more about my wife's experience with AllSafe in the next post, but it was an excellent experience overall. The only downside to the course at AllSafe is now my wife is going to get expensive considering all the ammunition I am going to have to buy her in the future.

Monday, March 31, 2008

The California Homeschooling Situation

Okay so most everyone has heard of the recent California Appellate Court ruling in In re Rachel L. that has seemingly outlawed homeschooling in California. I have been asked to write an 1800 word article about it for Liberty magazine.

To those ends, I have been doing a lot of reading, mostly of the original decision, but I have been reading opinions by the Home School Legal Defense Association, the CA Superintendent of Public Instruction, etc.

One intelligent blogger, Mr Timothy Power at Sometimes I'm Actually Coherent, has commented on the situation in several posts, That Court Case, Homeschooling & Constitutional Rights, A Trio of Powerful Allies, and I'm Not So Sure I Like Where This Is Heading...

In A Trio of Powerful Allies Mr. Power commented:

After some initial shock on my part, I took the time to familiarize myself with the ruling and the facts of the case, and I've become a bit more sanguine about the situation. The ruling still appears to be pretty sour on homeschooling in general. However, I didn't actually see anything in the ruling that changed the system homeschoolers operate under. Under state law, private schools are not required to have their teachers credentialed. So if parents follow the laws to establish private schools--with themselves as teachers and administrators, and their kids as the students, they're fine. The ruling said this arrangement probably wasn't what the legislature intended; but it didn't explicitly go on to ban the practice.

Later, in I'm Not Sure I Like Where This Is Going... Mr. Power continues in the same line of reasoning:

Through this all I've been much more sanguine about the meaning of the In Re: Rachel L. ruling than many. To this day I read in newspapers and on the sites of other bloggers that the ruling "outlawed the practice of Homeschooling by parents not possessing Teachers' credentials", which is absolutely not the case. This misconception is very widespread, by people on both sides of the issue.

[...]

Now, after reading the decision myself, I'll say it's certainly possible that this is what the court intended to say; but that's not what the actual text comes out saying, when taken in context with the applicable laws. And as I mentioned above, the State Superintendent had a legal review done and concluded that the ruling did not outlaw homeschooling by uncredentialed parents.


Now, I want Mr. Power to be correct. He is certainly a smarter guy than I am, IMO. (I console myself with the fact that I am much better looking.) Even though I teach both in the K12 public school system and the Community College system, I plan on homeschooling my children.

However, I believe Mr. Power, and others have misunderstood what the CA Appellate Court said. For example, I believe the California Department of Education got the intention of the Appellate Court wrong.

In a careful reading of the Rachel L. case, the Court appears clear that it understood the intent of Legislature was not to allow homeschooling via registering the home as a private school. In dealing with case under review, the Appellate Court cites and applies the Turner case in rejecting the notion of parents registering their home school under the private school option in the CA Ed Code. The Rachel L. Court decision states:
Additionally, the Turner court rejected, and noted that courts in other states had also rejected, the notion that parents instructing their children at home come within the private full-time day school exemption in then section 16624 (now section 48222). The court stated that a simple reading of the statutes governing private schools and home instruction by private tutors shows the Legislature intended to distinguish the two, for if a private school includes a parent or private tutor instructing a child at home, there would be no purpose in writing separate legislation for private instruction at home. (Turner, supra, 121 Cal.App.2d Supp. at p. 868; accord Shinn, supra, 195 Cal.App.2d at p. 693.) (Bold supplied.)

After rejected the notion parents utilizing the private school option in order to homeschool, the Court continued to say the parents in Rachel L. didn't even meet this option anyhow. The enrolled their children in Sunland Christian School's independent study program, which is only permitted for public schools by the California Ed. Code.

The Rachel L. Court continued:
Moreover, even if being taught at a parent’s home could be construed as attendance at a private day school, the parents in Turner had not demonstrated that their home already qualified as a private school under the requirements of the Education Code. (Turner, at p. 869.) (Bold supplied.)

Earlier in the Rachel L. Court's discussion of the Turner case, it became obvious it considered a private full-time day school to be in contrast to a "private school" home school option. The Court rejected the parents attempt to homeschool via enrolling in Sunland Christian School's independent study program, which the Court strongly negatively referred to as a "ruse."

Such representation does not constitute a statement that the Los Angeles Unified School District and the Los Angeles County Office of Education knowingly gave their stamp of approval to children being deprived of an education in a public or private full-time day school setting, or by a credentialed tutor, through the ruse of enrolling them in a private school and then letting them stay home and be taught by a non-credentialed parent. (Bold supplied.)

Throughout the Court's decision, it kept comparing and contrasting children going to a full-time day school that was either public or private where the child actually attends vs. parents keep the child at home at tutor them themselves.Where the Court goes after this is hard to say. The Court's discussion was a bit hard to follow, but its intent in its published opinion becomes clear with a careful reading.

Mr. Power also commented that:

The court issues a broad decision whose language goes far beyond the needs of the immediate litigants--making sweeping statements about the intent of the legislature and appearing, at first glance, to outlaw homeschooling by uncredentialed parents.

While I am sure Mr. Power knew this (but didn't say it for space considerations), the Appellate Court in Rachel L. did not itself make sweeping statements about the intent of the CA Legislature, but cited the statements of the court in the Turner case, as well as in other cases referenced in Turner.

The Court regarded itself as not making a new decision in this instance, but agree with prior courts' decisions Pierce, Turner, Shinn, Yoder, etc (many of which are cases decided by the U.S. Supreme Court) about compulsory education and homeschooling. The Rachel L. Court did not believe that it was outlawing homeschooling under the CA Constitution, but that homeschooling was not within the intent of CA Legislature in the CA Ed. Code, other Court cases clarified that homeschooling was unconstitutional, and the Rachel L. Court applied these prior decisions to the case at hand.

While I respect Mr. Power and want him to be right, it does not appear that is the case.



Thursday, March 27, 2008

Upcoming Topics

In the next few days I will be posting my thought both on the California Homeschooling situation, as well as the Jeremiah Wright situation with its implications about my voting for Barack Obama for president.

While I do not like the CA homeschooling decision that came out in the casde of Rachel L., I think many in the Christian community are mischaracterizing the situation. I recently head statements by Dr. James Dopbson and read an article by Mr Chuck Norris (or martial arts fame, and whose former home in Tustin, CA I lived in for 2 years) on Townhall.com that, while I agree with their basic conclusions, I disagree with their characterizations of the motives behind the Court that heard the caseor the teachers unions who like the outcome.

The radio broadcast of Dr. Dobson can be heard at http://listen.family.org/daily/A000000997.cfm

While I have not had a chance to listen to the audio yet, you might be interested in hearing the opinions of Law Professor Shaun Martin as the San Diego School of Law. His video opinion can be viewed at The Daily Case Report at http://www.dailycasereport.com/index.php?q=adv_sheet_by_case/3229

Monday, March 10, 2008

Sometimes I'm Actually Coherent: Homeschooling & Constitutional Rights

Mr. Timothy Power has written a nice little article entitled Homeschooling & Constitutional Rights on his blog. You can access it at this link: Sometimes I'm Actually Coherent: Homeschooling & Constitutional Rights.

Friday, January 11, 2008

Ron Paul Racist?

For a while, I was a bit intrigued by Ron Paul's ron for the presidency. While I never seriously considered voting for him because of his foreign policy views (i.e., essentially isolationist) and his oddball desire to return to the gold standard for currency, it is now all over the news that Ron paul has made (in the past) very serious, unacceptable, and immoral racist and anti-Semetic remarks.

According to the Houston Chronical (http://www.chron.com/content/chronicle/aol-metropolitan/96/05/23/paul.html) Ron Paul published a newsletter in the 80's and 90's referring to blacks as essentially criminals and made references to "Zionist" conspiracies.

According to a May 24, 1996 article by the Associated Press titled "Newsletter by Paul attacked" Ron Paul circulated a political newsletter to some 7,000 subscribers since 1985. The AP article noted that, in 1992 Paul circulated a newsletter that made comments of the sort

If you have ever been robbed by a black teen-aged male, you know how
unbelievably fleet-footed they can be.

The AP artcile continued:

Citing statistics from a 1992 study produced by the National Center on Incarceration and Alternatives, a criminal justice think tank based in Virginia, Paul concluded in his column: "Given the inefficiencies of what DC laughingly calls the criminal justice system, I think we can safely assume that 95 percent of the black males in that city are semi criminal or entirely criminal."


"These aren't my figures," Paul said this week. "That is the assumption you can gather from" the report.


He also wrote: "Opinion polls consistently show that only about 5 percent of blacks have sensible political opinions, i.e. support the free market, individual liberty and the end of welfare and affirmative action."


Paul continued that politically sensible blacks are outnumbered "as decent people."


Such comments are not only racist and immoral, but are also just plain stupid. Such comments make him unfit for the position of Commander-in-Chief. I cannot vote for this man.

Monday, December 03, 2007

The Levitt Letter

Recently, an anonymous Seventh-day Adventist wrote an objectionable letter to the Zola Levitt Ministries (http://www.levitt.com/). This letter was published (Adventists Are Now God's Chosen People!?) in the December 2007 Levitt Letter and Dr. Jeffrey Seif rightly responded to the objectionable contents.

Embarassed and offended by what this anonymous Adventist wrote, I called Zola Levitt Ministries (25 Nov. '07) and left a message for Dr. Seif apologizing for what this guy wrote. Not satisfied with only a phone message, I decided to write Dr. Seif an apology email responding to the comments of the letter.

I am including both the letter and Dr. Seif's response below, and then I am following with the email I sent Dr. Seif. I have made minor editorical changes.



Adventists Are Now God’s Chosen People!?
Dear Jeffrey,
God has rejected the Jews because they rejected Him. I am a Seventh Day Adventist and our prophet Ellen G. White was told by God that the Jews would never be a Nation again and that Old Jerusalem would never be rebuilt. The Adventists are now God’s chosen people, “Spiritual Israel.” The Jews can come to Jesus by becoming Adventists.

You seem to be afraid of the Muslims, but it’s the Catholics you need to worry about. The Pope is the antiChrist and Sunday is the “Mark of the Beast”! The Muslims are nearest to the Adventist faith because they have a prophet, don’t eat pork, and go to church on Friday like we do. The Adventist Church in Europe turned all of their Jewish converts over to Hitler and most died in the ovens. God said they would—read Lev. 26. I’m afraid to put my name to this for fear the Jews may try to kill me.

Dear Whatever-Your-Name-Is—
I believe that your letter is loaded with an inordinate amount of fantasy. Saying that the Jews may try to kill you is absolutely absurd, as are other statements, like “Sunday is the ‘Mark of the Beast.’” I don’t want to sound cold. Honestly, however, I think your thought process leaps beyond the pale of reason. I would strongly encourage you to invest your energies in realworld pursuits; as a theologian, you are out of this world.— Jeffrey Seif
The Levitt Letter, December 2007, page 23.
http://www.levitt.com/newsletters/2007-12.pdf


From: bakupulu@hotmail.com
To: staff@levitt.com
CC: bakupulu@hotmail.com
Subject: Please Forward to Dr. Jeffrey Seif
Date: Thu, 29 Nov 2007 13:48:40 -0800

Dear Dr. Seif:

At the outset, I want to apologize for the outrageous and reprehensible comments made by the Seventh-day Adventist who wrote the anonymous letter printed in your December 2007 newletter. To state or imply (and the author certainly did imply it), much less believe, that the mass murder of millions of Jews by the Nazi's is anything but an evil event in history, is shameful and unacceptable.

As an Adventist layman I am grieved and shocked to have read such comments made by someone ostensibly from my denomination. Such beliefs and comments do not come from the heart of a Christian (Matt. 12:35,-37; James 3:10).

The author's comments proceeded from being grossly and crudely stated, to comments that are flat out wrong, to those comments that are evil. I want to address some of these indiviually as they occur in the letter (below).



Adventists Are Now God’s Chosen People!?

Dear Jeffrey,

God has rejected the Jews because they rejected Him. I am a Seventh Day Adventist and our prophet Ellen G. White


The latter comment is a true but misleading and crudely stated comment. The official Adventist position is that, while we believe Ellen White had the gift of prophecy like that manifested in the New Testament church like Paul mentioned in Corinthians, Ellen White does not have normative authority. Her own writings, and the denominations statements, make it clear that "the Bible is the standard by which all teaching and experience must be tested." (http://www.adventist.org/beliefs/fundamental/index.html)

Yes, it is true that there are those who have (unfortunately) treated her work as though it is equal to Scripture, but that is a problem within the denomination, not the position or desire of the denomination. An important and recent discussion on this topic can be found in Dr. Graeme Brandfor's new book More Than a Prophet: How We Lost and Found Again the Real Ellen White. I was one of the editor's for the published book and the entire book can be read online at http://www.sdanet.org/atissue/books/bradford/index.htm.


was told by God that the Jews would never be a Nation again and that Old Jerusalem would never be rebuilt.
In short, Ellen White was not speaking of whether or not it would be rebuilt in the sense of a political solution to a political problem. She was responding to those who thought they were forcing prophecy to be fulfilled in the 1850s by speeding up Jesus' return (in the 1850s) by rebulding Jerusalem. (http://www.whiteestate.org/issues/faq-unus.html#unusual-section-d2)


The Adventists are now God’s chosen people, “Spiritual Israel.”

The official Adventist position, and mainstream teaching, is that salvation is not through denominational affiliation (including ours) and the majority of true Christians exist outside the Seventh-day Adventist denomination. Our official 27 Fundamental Beliefs state that "The church is the community of believers who confess Jesus Christ as Lord and Saviour" and "The universal church is composed of all who truly believe in Christ ..." (http://www.adventist.org/beliefs/fundamental/index.html). Official Adventist teaching does state we are the "remnant," but not in the sense that "we are the saved" or that "we are the true Spiritual Israel," or that we are better than other denominations, but merely that we have a special job to do, namely:

"The universal church is composed of all who truly believe in Christ, but in the last days, a time of widespread apostasy, a remnant has been called out to keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus. This remnant announces the arrival of the judgment hour, proclaims salvation through Christ, and heralds the approach of His second advent." (http://www.adventist.org/beliefs/fundamental/index.html).


The Jews can come to Jesus by becoming Adventists.

Wrong. You come to Jesus by coming to Jesus, not to any denomination. However, any and all are welcome to our denomination. We are willing to accept all the help we can get.


You seem to be afraid of the Muslims, but it’s the Catholics you need to worry about. The Pope is the antiChrist and Sunday is the “Mark of the Beast”! The Muslims are nearest to the Adventist faith because they have a prophet, don’t eat pork, and go to church on Friday like we do.
I have respect for all Muslims who behave decently. I am willing to live in civic and neighborly harmony with them. However, strictly speaking, those who are closest to Adventists are those whose beliefs are closest to our 27 Fundamental Beliefs (http://www.adventist.org/beliefs/fundamental/index.html).

I am not saying those who are closest to Adventists (because they hold views similar to our 27 Fundamental Beliefs) are by definition somehow closest to Jesus. Those who are closest to Jesus are those who have the closest personal, living relationship with Jesus Christ of the Bible, not those who automatically adhere to the tenants of any church.

The Adventist Church in Europe turned all of their Jewish converts over to Hitler and most died in the ovens.
Like many churches in Europe at that time, much of the European Adventist Church did not live up to its Christian calling by resisting the Nazis and helping Jews. While this was not the position of the mainline SDA Church, nor something that the denomination as a whole wanted, much of this did occur. It was cowardly and evil. While words are not enough, it has been acknowleged and apologized for (http://www.adventistreview.org/article.php?id=92).

God said they would—read Lev. 26. I’m afraid to put my name to this for fear the Jews may try to kill me.
Like I said at the outset, the author's comments and the implications that they contain are unacceptable. In my opinion and experience, this guy is a nut and does not represent the typical Adventist, much less the official Adventist Church position. Frankly, I hope this guy is not really an Adventist at all, and is someone who is playing a sick practical joke.

Further information can be found at the official Adventist Church website (http://www.adventist.org/) and the Adventist Biblical Research website (http://www.adventistbiblicalresearch.org/). Respected and representative scholars are Dr. Jon Paulien (http://revelation-armageddon.com/ and http://www.thebattleofarmageddon.com/) and Dr. Samuele Bacchiocchi (http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/).

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

Weight Training Gains

Okay, I have been lifting weights for about a year now. One of my buddies at work started me on it by nagging my to get back in the gym. Well, after 10 years of sedentary married life and being very weak and too fat (I am also 5'6" tall), I have brought up my 1 rep max in each of the following:

Flat Bench Press = 315 lbs x 1
Deadlift = 365 lbs x 1
Squat = 535 lbs x 2
Not that the squat of 535 (two times) was not done free weights (I am too nervous for that yet), but was on the Hammer Strength Power Squat machine. I have been training as a powerlifter (though I am nowhere near their level of strength) not as a body builder. I am interested in maximum strength, not so much size and symmetry.
I made these gains following two different linear periodized routines, both of which I got from The Iron Dungeon (http://www.impulseadventure.com/weights/). One is a 6-session routine while the other is a 14-session routine. These routines were for bench press only, but I used the same percentages and repetitions, etc and applied them to deadlifts, squats, etc.
I just started doing Charle's Poliquin's 1-6 routine(http://www.wannabebigforums.com/archive/index.php/t-34687.html) and it is wearing me out, but I have been getting stronger as the routine claims.
For example, I was doing my first day of 1-6 deadlifts, and my max deadlifts increased from 365 to 370 to 375 lbs all in one session. I know this won't automatically mean longterm gains in themselves, but it is working.
My summer goals are to get my bench press up to 405 lbs, my deadlift to 500 lbs, and my (free weight) squat too 450 lbs. I now this is a lot to hope for, but I am gonna try anyway.

Tuesday, September 04, 2007

Science versus Intelligent Design

Science versus Intelligent Design


As Featured On Ezine Articles


I belong to a newsgroup called SDANet (http://www.sdanet.org/). In two posts to that newsgroup, I made the statement that “one must do mathematics and philosophy before one can do science.”

My purpose in those two posts was to drive home the point that scientists have certain philosophic assumptions before they even engage in scientific inquiry. In fact, the process of science itself is founded on certain assumptions about the world around us.

In this article, I want the reader to realize the scientific community disregards Intelligent Design as “religion and not science” because it violates their a priori philosophic presuppositions about what they believe science is. These scientists confuse their philosophy of materialism, methodological naturalism, scientism, what-have-you with science itself.

The purpose of the current article is twofold.

First, I want to point out how certain philosophic assumptions are embedded as the foundation of the Scientific Method. From this illustration, I hope the reader realizes the truth of “one must do mathematics and philosophy before one can do science.” I am not attempting to analyze or critique every philosophy of science (e.g., materialism, methodological naturalism, etc), but just to illustrate that philosophic presuppositions come before the scientific process itself.

The second part of this article is to illustrate errors with one common approach to scientific inquiry, namely Methodological Naturalism. Methodological Naturalism can be summed up (albeit a bit simplistically) as the assertion that only naturalistic causes are to be used as explanations of phenomenon that scientists investigate.

Methodological Naturalism is the philosophic assumption (i.e., it cannot be demonstrated to true by scientific investigation itself) that is very commonly used as an argument against Intelligent Design advocates. In other words, the scientific community argues that “since (we assume) science can only appeal to naturalistic causes, and Intelligent Design by its very nature does not restrict itself to naturalistic causes, then Intelligent Design advocates are not doing true science; rather they are doing religion in disguise.”

Please note, again, this is what the scientific community presupposes ahead of time what “science really is.” It is a position that is argued for and is not demonstrated through scientific investigation. Indeed, the scientific community cannot, and does not, justify Methodological Naturalism experimentally or through scientific investigation, but by appeals to what they consider sound reasoning.

Part 1: Presuppositions Embedded within the Scientific Method

Here I attempt to illustrate how using the Scientific Method is based upon certain inherent assumed views about the world around us. I am not attempting to prove these true or false, but to make it clear that scientific inquiry is based upon certain presuppositions.

Someone might disagree with my examples of the inherent assumptions in the Scientific Method and offer alternative ones. But this still illustrates that one has some philosophic presuppositions about the world before they even engage in scientific endeavors.

There are a number of ways the Scientific Method can be outlined, but one reasonable representation of it is as follows:

Observation --> Hypothesis --> Test Hypothesis --> Conclusions
All of these steps of the Scientific Method are based on the following philosophic assumptions.


A. The External World Objectively Exists – “The external world exists, whether you know it or not, whether you like it or not.” If the world was merely illusionary and a figment of my imagination, it would be erroneous to investigate why certain phenomena occurred as it is merely my imagination.

Please note that one might not know the external world was imaginary and one might try to investigate this (illusory) external world anyway.

But it would still be faulty to do so because if the external world is a truly product of your imagination, there is no real need to investigate why things happened. They did not truly happen, you merely imagined it.

However, the assumption that the external world truly exists is why scientists make hypotheses to explain certain phenomenon, and why they need to test their hypotheses, i.e., we test our hypotheses because our explanation may not actually be correct, despite what we think.

In short, Reality is what you bump into when your beliefs are wrong.

B. The External World Is Governed by Consistent Laws – there would be no point in investigating the behavior of the world if the rules governing the universe were randomly changed without warning. Any discovery made today would be invalid shortly thereafter.

C. The Correspondence Theory of Truth – a true statement or true hypothesis is one that accurately describes the way the external world really is. Scientists are supposed to be in the business of determining what really is going on. Ultimately, I would argue that most scientists are not looking for an erroneous model that works, but what really is going on.

Again, Part 1 is not intended to prove the exact specifics of the philosophic assumptions embedded in the Scientific Method. It was intended to illustrate that all scientists, whether they know it or not, whether they like it or not, operate on certain a priori presuppositions about the world around us. They also operate on certain a priori philosophic presuppositions of what “science really is.”

Part 2. Problems with Methodological Naturalism.

One of the common assumptions about what “science really is” is called Methodological Naturalism. Methodological Naturalism asserts that only appeals to naturalistic causes are legitimate in scientific inquiry. Often they also claim to restrict this to repeatable naturalistic causes.

The first flaw with this approach to define what “science really is” is that it first assumed and argued for, not proven. One cannot demonstrate through scientific investigation and appealing to only naturalistic causes, that the only proper approach to science is Methodological Naturalism. I know of no experimental study that demonstrates the truth of the Methodological Naturalism assumption. I know of no scientists who propose Methodological Naturalism on anything other than (what they consider to be) sound logical grounds.

Regardless of whether or not their arguments for Methodological Naturalism are sound, it still demonstrates that it is philosophically argued for.

The second flaw with Methodological Naturalism is that before scientific inquiry even begins, it limits itself to only certain conclusions allowed as the product of this scientific investigation. Rather than employ the Scientific Method and then use inference to the best explanation, Methodological Naturalism rules in advance that certain conclusions are not permitted, despite the weight of the evidence and the reasonableness of the conclusions.

This is roughly equivalent to homicide investigators being told that, before the investigation even begins, they are not allowed interpret the evidence such that they conclude a woman committed the crime.

To illustrate further, suppose you placed a closed box in front of a biologist and asked her explain what is going on inside the box.
When the box is opened, the biologist clearly sees an Oreo cookie inside a glass of milk.

What would be the most reasonable way for the biologist to explain how the Oreo got in the glass? Would she restrict herself to Methodological Naturalism and only appeal to naturalistic causes? Or would she infer an intelligent cause for this phenomenon and conclude someone was putting her on?

Or, more to the point, here is a more realistic illustration. What would happen if a NASA satellite truly did intercept an electromagnetic signal from a star-system that is 500 light years away. This signal consisted of 1,000 prime numbers in the sequence, i.e., 1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 11, 13, 17, 19, 23, 29, … etc.

Would it be appropriate to insist Methodological Naturalism is the only way NASA is permitted analyze the data? Must NASA therefore assume purely naturalistic causes for this sequence of numbers no matter the weight of the evidence to the contrary? Or would it be more appropriate to make an inference to the best explanation and suspect an intelligent cause for this sequence of numbers?

In both cases listed above, I suspect that scientists would assume intelligent causes rather than purely naturalistic causes. This is where Methodological Naturalism falters and Intelligent Design comes in. Any school-child would figure out someone put the Oreo cookie into the glass of milk. Also, once human sources were truly ruled out, any astronomer or cryptographer (or school-child) would be reasonable to raise the possibility of the signal being originated by an intelligent source outside our solar system.

However, it is very reasonable to ask, What is an appropriate algorithm for determining Intelligent Design? How can one reasonably infer Intelligent Design in an observed phenomenon? The method is based upon spotting a phenomenon that is (1) a low probability event and is, (2) specified in advance.

(1) Low Probability Event: Any event, no matter how low the probability (assuming not zero), will occur if given enough time. If I take a deck of cards, and throw them into the air, the exact order and location of how they fall on the floor is a low probability event. One would not be reasonable in inferring Intelligent Design from this. Given enough time (1 million years?) to throw the deck of cards into the air, you could replicate this event if you were patient enough.

(2) Specification in Advance: Any event specified in advance that is not of sufficiently low probability does not suggest Intelligent Design. For example, if I were to tell you the sun will rise tomorrow, you would not be impressed. If I told you there would be an earthquake in Los Angeles area in the next 50 years, you would not be impressed. Yes, I specified it in advance, but it is not exactly a low probability event.

However, both (1) and (2) combined can be used to indicate Intelligent Design.

For example, were NASA to intercept an electromagnetic signal that was a random string of 1,000 numbers, this would not imply intelligent design. Sure, the exact order of a random string of 1,000 numbers is a low probability event, but such things occur in nature (e.g., white noise).

Also, if NASA intercepted a string of the first 4 prime numbers, 1, 2, 3, and 5, they likely would not call SETI and announce contact with space aliens. Yes, it is a numeric sequence specified in advance, but the sequence is so short that it is not of sufficiently low probability to infer an intelligent source.

However, a string of the first 1,000 prime numbers is both a very low probability event, and also shows specification in advance. There is no known natural phenomenon that produces the prime numbers, much less the first 1,000 of them! I think by this time the NASA would feel confident in calling SETI and the President to report their findings. (Assuming of course, they *truly* ruled out a human source for the signal.)

In parting, I hope that I made it clear that the furor over Intelligent Design is not a conflict between empirical science and religion. It is a conflict between worldviews and what evidence is allowed to inform the discussion.

The author is deeply indebted to the folks at Stand to Reason (http://www.STR.org) and Dr. William Debski for man of the ideas and illustrations in this article. Any limitations are errors are mine alone.

Thursday, August 23, 2007

Hung Gar Kung Fu



I am also starting to re-train myself in Hung Gar kung fu, the martial art I learned when I was much younger. I am doing this for a few reasons. First, because I did not give it the time it deserved when I was younger, and this is something I want to do for myself as I approach the ripe old age of 40. Second, I want to be able to protect myself or my family if, God-forbid, something bad happens. Third, I learned such valuable lesson from Hung Gar, especially perseverance and martial virtue, that I want my son to learn the art when he is old enough. I hope to be able to take him to Sifu Bucksam Kong's Hung Gar school.

Currently, I am re-learning the Hung Gar set (sort of like a karate 'kata') Gung Gee Fook Fu Kuen from Sifu Wong Lam's resources. If you are interested in learning more about Kung Fu, including Hung Gar, you can check out the Wing Lam Enterprises website and forums by checking my links to the right.

I have also started training in Shaolin Iron Palm and hope to incorporate Tiger Iron Palm in a couple of years. After just a few months of training (on the beginner Mung bean bag), I can already tell a difference in the increased strength and dexterity of my hands.

Lastly, I have also just started the practice of Zhan Zheong qigong. I will more into this later.

Weight Training Again


Well, I have started weight training again after letting myself get seriously out of shape. I started using a periodized weight training routine that I found on the Impulse Adventure Iron Dungeon website (see links). Since then, my strength has increased dramatically. For example, I have gone from being completely sedentary to bench pressing over 315 lbs in about 5 months! (I am only 5'6" tall.)

I will also be going on a nonlinear periodized weight training routine and will publish some book reviews on the topic.

Thursday, March 23, 2006

Death Of A Hero


Desmond T. Doss, Sr., has died at 87 years of age. He was the only conscientious objector to win the Congressional Medal of Honor during World War II and a long-time member of the Georgia-Cumberland Conference of Seventh-day Adventists.

Doss passed away Thursday morning, March 23, 2006, at his residence in Piedmont, Alabama. He is survived by his wife Frances, his son, Desmond T. Doss, Jr., and his brother, Harold Doss. He was preceded in death by his first wife Dorothy Schutte and his sister Audrey Millner.

Doss never liked being called a conscientious objector. He preferred the term conscientious cooperator. Raised a Seventh-day Adventist, Doss did not believe in using a gun or killing because of the sixth commandment which states, “Thou shalt not kill” (Exodus 20:13). Doss was a patriot however, and believed in serving his country.

During World War II, instead of accepting a deferment, Doss voluntarily joined the Army as a conscientious objector. Assigned to the 307th Infantry Division as a company medic he was harassed and ridiculed for his beliefs, yet he served with distinction and ultimately received the Congressional Medal of Honor on October 12, 1945 for his fearless acts of bravery.

According to his Medal of Honor citation, time after time, Doss’ fellow soldiers witnessed how unafraid he was for his own safety. He was always willing to go after a wounded fellow, no matter how great the danger. On one occasion in Okinawa, he refused to take cover from enemy fire as he rescued approximately 75 wounded soldiers, carrying them one-by-one and lowering them over the edge of the 400-foot Maeda Escarpment. He did not stop until he had brought everyone to safety nearly 12 hours later.

When Doss received the Medal of Honor from President Truman, the President told him, “I’m proud of you, you really deserve this. I consider this a greater honor than being President.”

Doss’ exemplary devotion to God and his country has received nationwide attention. On July 4, 2004, a statue of Doss was placed in the National Museum of Patriotism in Atlanta, Ga., along with statues of Dr. Martin Luther King, President Jimmy Carter, and retired Marine Corps General Gray Davis, also a Medal of Honor recipient. Also in 2004, a feature-length documentary called “The Conscientious Objector,” telling Doss’ story of faith, heroism, and bravery was released. A feature movie describing Doss’ story is also being planned.


A memorial service will be held April 1, 2006, at 3:00 p.m. at the Collegedale Seventh-day Adventist Church in Collegedale, Tenn. In Lieu of flowers, the Doss family requests that donations may be sent to the Desmond Doss Museum Fund at the Georgia-Cumberland Conference office (P.O. Box 12000 Calhoun, GA 30703).